Trump vs Harvard
By Cody Andrus
A troubling conflict has unfolded between President Trump and Harvard University that will likely harm the U.S. and its place in the world. This clash, particularly concerning international students, highlights a shortsighted approach that could have long-lasting, negative effects on American research, innovation, and even economic strength. The ordeal seems ridiculous to many, including myself, yet the potential consequences are very serious.
President Trump's policies have always made it harder for international students to come to the U.S. and stay after graduation. One example was the threat to revoke visas for international students whose universities moved all classes online during the pandemic. This policy, later rescinded, caused widespread confusion and concern among students and institutions alike. The idea that a student who chose to study in the U.S., investing significant time and money, could suddenly be forced to leave because of a change in university policy was truly alarming. This is part of a broader pattern where the U.S. has appeared less welcoming to talented individuals from other countries.
Harvard, like many top U.S. universities, relies heavily on international students who bring a diverse range of perspectives, cultures, and, quite often, intellectual firepower. They fill critical roles in graduate programs, especially in science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) fields. In 2023, international students made up 23.3% of all students enrolled in U.S. higher education, contributing significantly to the academic and research landscape. Many of these students go on to become leading researchers, entrepreneurs, and innovators. When fewer international students can come to Harvard or other U.S. institutions, the pipeline of talent diminishes.
This reduction in international student enrollment will directly impact research and development. U.S. universities are hubs for groundbreaking research, much of which is funded by federal grants and private investment. This research often relies on collaborative teams, and international students are often key members of these teams. They contribute to breakthroughs in medicine, technology, and other vital areas. If the best and brightest minds from around the world are deterred from studying in the U.S., universities will struggle to maintain their leading edge in research. This can lead to a decline in the number of patents filed, fewer new businesses created, and a slower pace of scientific discovery. The U.S. risks losing its position as a global leader in innovation.
Beyond research, there is a significant financial impact. International students often pay full tuition, which helps support university operations, faculty salaries, and financial aid for domestic students. In the 2022-2023 academic year, international students contributed nearly $40.9 billion to the U.S. economy and supported over 368,000 jobs. A drop in international enrollment means a loss of revenue for universities, which can lead to budget cuts, fewer resources for students, and a diminished capacity to attract and retain talented faculty.
The New York Times. "Trump Administration Rescinds Rule on International Students and Online Classes." July 14, 2020.Reuters. "U.S. to Revoke Visas for Foreign Students Whose Classes Go Online." July 6, 2020.AP News. "International Students Contribute Billions to US Economy." November 15, 2023.The Wall Street Journal. "Foreign Student Enrollment in U.S. Reaches Record High." November 13, 2023.NAFSA: Association of International Educators. "International Student Economic Value Tool." 2023.Institute of International Education (IIE). "Open Doors 2023 Report." 2023.
